What is new mover marketing?
Updated: 2 days ago
New mover marketing means welcoming people who just moved into your area with a gift from your business, usually in their first few weeks in the new home. A new household has no favorite coffee shop, pizza place, grocery store or hardware store yet. The first local business that reaches out and gives them a reason to come in has a real shot at becoming their regular.

I've been doing this for over 11 years, and Our Town has been welcoming new neighbors since 1972. Here's how it works, and what it looks like for real stores.
Why new movers matter to a local business
Your regulars didn't always shop with you. At some point they tried you for the first time, and moving is one of the few moments when almost everyone is looking for new places at once.
Think about what one regular is worth. On our grocery page I use this math: the average shopper makes about 1.6 trips a week. That's roughly 83 trips a year, or about $8,788 in groceries a year at $169 a week. Win one new household early, and that's what you're competing for.
The timing matters too. A few months after the move, they've settled into routines. If a competitor reached them first, you're trying to change a habit instead of starting one.
How it works
You pick your area. We start with a few ZIP codes, a radius or a drive time around your store. It depends on how far your customers usually travel.
We find the new households. Every month we pull the people who just moved in. Our list goes through a 14-step verification, so you're not paying to mail people who only refinanced or changed a utility account.
They get a welcome gift from you. A real gift with nothing to buy, like a free drink, a free pizza or $10 off with no minimum. Your business is the only one of its kind in the package, so you're not sharing the spotlight with a competitor.
They come in and redeem it. Each gift has its own code. Your team scans the certificates in the back office with TruTrak®, and you see every new customer who came in.
A thank-you postcard brings them back. About 10 days after their code is scanned, they get a thank-you card with a second offer. That second visit is often where the habit starts.
We handle the list, design, printing and mailing. Your job is to welcome them when they walk in.
What it looks like for real stores
These are local stores and single franchise locations, not national averages. Each one links to the full case study.
Ridley's Family Markets, Kuna, Idaho (local grocery): 1,388 new customers from August 2019 to March 2024. 15% of everyone mailed came in.
Kabat's Ace Hardware (local hardware): 1,350 new customers in 12 months, a 9.5% response and $17K in additional sales.
Baskin's Ace Hardware, Cape Cod (local hardware): 181 new customers in 5 months in 2023, and still mailing today.
Dairy Queen, Phoenix (franchise): 145 new customers in 7 months from one ZIP code, with nine competitors within 2 miles.
Little Caesars (franchise): an 8.6% response, about 26 new customers a month from 300 households per store.
Christina Martin of Manizza's Pizza in Las Vegas had a new customer in her lobby within an hour of the mail landing. She says she'd pay double for it.
Why it has to fit your business
New mover marketing needs to be customized to your business. You can't just buy a list from a data source and start mailing. First, really think about:
Who you're trying to reach.
What the timing should look like.
What kind of offer will make sense to them.
Whether your business is even ripe for new movers. It might not be at all. For an orthodontist, families with kids in the right age range can matter more than who just moved in.
And not all data sources are created equal, especially for new movers. Some lists pick up people who only refinanced or changed a utility account. That's why ours goes through a 14-step verification. More questions I hear about mailing lists.
What makes a good new mover offer
The gift asks for nothing. That's the part people underestimate. When someone gives us something with no strings, we naturally want to return the favor. So new neighbors come in and give you a try.
A few things I've learned:
Make it a real gift. A free item or $10 to $20 off with no minimum works better than a percent off with a minimum purchase.
Personalize the mailing. Both the envelope and the welcome certificate have the new neighbor's name on them, so it feels like a real welcome from you, not just another ad.
Give them time. People sometimes bring in their welcome gift 4, 8 or 12 weeks later. I often use "Offer expires in 90 days" instead of a fixed date. More on expiration dates.
Plan the second visit. The thank-you postcard is what turns one visit into a habit.
Questions I hear about new mover marketing
Is it only for homeowners?
No. We reach new homeowners and new renters, so the apartments and rentals near your store count too.
What response should I expect?
Across my clients it usually runs about 8 to 9%. Some restaurants pull closer to 20%, and dentists and healthcare run lower. It depends on your offer and your business, so I won't promise a number.
How do I know it's working?
Every gift has its own code. Your team scans the certificates in the back office with TruTrak®, at the end of the day or once a week, and you see each new customer. If we link the code to your POS, you can see what they spent too.
How many households do I need?
I usually recommend at least 300 new households a month per location. That gives you a steady stream of new faces instead of a trickle.
Is it just for big brands?
No. I work with independent stores and franchise owners. For a local store, it's one of the best ways to stand out against a big chain's ad budget.
I'm an Ace store. Do I need co-op funds?
No. New mover mail for hardware stores usually pays for itself with what new customers spend. If you have Ace co-op funds, the program qualifies, and that's a bonus.
Want to see the numbers for your area?
I can tell you how many new households move in near your store each month and what a welcome gift could look like for your business. Book a call, call or text me at 480-678-1366, or email hello@ourtowndirectmail.com.
Comments